API requests returns no data or status code on 1 of 3 deployed servers


We are deploying to several servers and only one server is giving us trouble out of 3 that have the exact same code.
Any guidance or places to look for why I would not be getting any response would be great!
The server that is giving us trouble is not returning any response codes or any data that I can see.

I am using the TwitterAPIExchange Lib

$url = 'https://api.twitter.com/1.1/statuses/show.json';
$getfield = '?id='.$id;
$requestMethod = 'GET';
$twitter = new TwitterAPIExchange($settings);
return $twitter->setGetfield($getfield)
         ->buildOauth($url, $requestMethod)

Server with successful curl

Server with failed response